Tag: comparison boundary

  • Alto CO2 rounding error

    ALTO: A CO2 Rounding Error

    What a high-speed railway contributes to transport decarbonisation, measured against the vehicles on the roads beside it.

    ⚠ The Comparison ALTO’s Business Case Does Not Make

    Over the fifty operating years from ALTO’s first phase opening in 2040 to 2089, at the Initiative’s central ridership forecast and on a consistent life-cycle accounting boundary, ALTO is a net carbon removal of 2.5 Mt CO2e. Electrifying the car and light-truck fleet of Ontario and Quebec over the same period removes 1,097 Mt. Electrifying the heavy trucks removes a further 154 to 668 Mt, depending how fast long-haul freight converts.

    ALTO is between 0.14 and 0.20 per cent of that total.

    Critical Finding

    ALTO is not a material decarbonisation instrument. Road electrification in the two provinces the corridor runs through averages about 28 Mt a year across the period. ALTO’s entire fifty-year net carbon removal is equivalent to roughly one month of it.

    The result is not an artefact of a pessimistic ridership assumption or a hostile accounting convention. It is computed on the most favourable boundary available to the railway: every mode carries its fuel supply chain and its manufacturing, so the electrification figures are already net of battery production and ALTO’s figure is already net of its 14.69 Mt of construction carbon. Measured the narrower way — tailpipe only, as ALTO’s own published material does — ALTO’s position is worse, not better.

    At ALTO’s upper ridership case, a forecast above every independent estimate for the corridor, its share reaches 1.3 to 1.8 per cent. At its lower case it is not a saving at all: the railway emits more over fifty years than it displaces. And ALTO does not repay its own construction carbon until 2083 — six years before the fifty-year operating period closes.

    One contextual finding frames everything below. The federal Electric Vehicle Availability Standard was paused in September 2025 and its repeal posted in the Canada Gazette in August 2026, with nothing in force to replace it. Restoring that mandate’s original trajectory would save a further 165 Mt over the same fifty years in these two provinces alone — roughly sixty-seven times ALTO’s entire net carbon removal. One regulatory decision about car sales outweighs the railway by nearly two orders of magnitude.

    Download
    ALTO: A CO2 Rounding Error — Full Note (PDF)
    Six pages, three tables, four figures — the full method, the fifty-year carbon account, and the four qualifications that belong with the comparison
    Download PDF
    The Finding

    What ALTO saves, and what else is happening

    ALTO is advanced, in part, as a climate measure. This note asks a question: how much carbon does it actually save, set against the other things happening to road transport in the same provinces over the same fifty years?

    2.5 Mt
    ALTO’s net carbon removal over fifty years, central ridership
    net of 14.69 Mt construction carbon
    1,097 Mt
    removed by car and light-truck electrification, Ontario + Quebec
    post-repeal trajectory, same period
    0.17%
    ALTO’s share of combined road electrification, central cases
    range 0.14% to 0.20%

    The three measures are drawn to scale below. ALTO is the narrow band at the right-hand edge; at this scale it is close to the width of the line that marks it.

    Car and light-truck electrification
    1,097 Mt · 77%
    Heavy-truck electrification
    324 Mt · 23%
    ALTO
    2.5 Mt · 0.17%
    Fifty-year totals, 2040–2089, Ontario and Quebec, life-cycle comparison boundary. Heavy trucks shown at the central conversion case (50 per cent of long-haul by 2080).
    Measure50-year savingALTO central as a share
    Car and light-truck electrification, Ontario + Quebec1,097 Mt—
    Heavy-truck electrification — slow25% of long-haul converted by 2080154 Mt—
    Heavy-truck electrification — central50% by 2080324 Mt—
    Heavy-truck electrification — fast90% by 2080, Pembina-aligned668 Mt—
    Combined road electrification — slow truck case1,251 Mt0.20 %
    Combined road electrification — central truck case1,422 Mt0.17 %
    Combined road electrification — fast truck case1,765 Mt0.14 %
    ALTO — lower ridership6.1M passengers a year by 2080−8.3 Mta net emitter
    ALTO — central ridership12.5M by 2080+2.5 Mt—
    ALTO — upper ridership25.7M by 2080, above every independent forecast+22.6 Mt—

    Table 1. Fifty-year carbon saving, 2040–2089, Ontario and Quebec. All figures on a life-cycle comparison boundary: every mode carries its fuel supply chain and its manufacturing, so the electrification figures are already net of battery production and ALTO’s figure is already net of its construction carbon. A negative figure means the measure emits more than it saves.

    The Railway’s Account

    What ALTO saves, and what it costs to build

    ALTO’s saving is the difference between what its passengers would otherwise have emitted and what the railway emits instead, less the carbon spent building it.

    The project opens in three phases — Montréal–Ottawa around 2040, Ottawa–Toronto around 2045, Montréal–Québec City around 2050 — and incurs construction carbon at each. The central estimate for the full 1,000 km corridor is 14.69 Mt CO2e, with a range of 6.87 to 29.60 Mt. Operations over fifty years add a further 2.9 Mt, and permanently severed rural roads a further 0.19 Mt.

    Against that, the displaced trips. On the Initiative’s central ridership trajectory the corridor carries 0.4 million passengers in 2040, 9.2 million by 2055 and 12.5 million by 2080, at a demand-weighted average trip of 430 km. Crediting those trips at the life-cycle intensity of the modes they replace — cars, short-haul aircraft, and the existing VIA Rail service — gives 20.2 Mt of displaced emission over the fifty years.

    ComponentMt CO2e
    Construction, one-time, central estimate+14.69
    Traction, 50 years+0.52
    Fixed operational — stations, maintenance, winter operations+2.29
    Road severance, 50 years+0.19
    Passenger modal shift, 50 years−20.15
    Net fifty-year balance−2.46

    Table 2. ALTO’s fifty-year carbon account, central ridership, IESO 2025 grid outlook, life-cycle comparison boundary. Positive is emission, negative is saving.

    The debt is front-loaded and the repayment is back-loaded

    The concrete is poured in the 2030s and 2040s; the passengers arrive in the 2060s and 2070s. ALTO does not repay its own construction carbon until 2083 — six years before the fifty-year operating period closes, and more than three decades after the date by which Canada’s climate targets fall due.

    The credit is shrinking as it is earned

    ALTO’s saving depends on the carbon intensity of the cars it displaces, which is falling as the fleet electrifies. The saving from moving one passenger out of a car falls from about 57 to about 22 grams per passenger-kilometre between 2050 and 2080 on the operational boundary. The displaced car is getting cleaner whether or not the railway is built.

    The accounting boundary decides the number — and this note uses the generous one

    The narrower tailpipe boundary counts only what comes out of the exhaust while travelling: no refinery, no factory, no battery. Measured that way the displaced cars look cleaner than they are, ALTO’s credit shrinks, and its payback moves from 2083 to 2110. Neither boundary is wrong; mixing them is. Every figure in this note uses the life-cycle boundary, which is the one that favours the railway.

    The Comparison

    What road electrification saves

    The comparison is built from the same inventory the federal government uses, and the same accounting boundary applied to ALTO.

    Natural Resources Canada’s Comprehensive Energy Use Database reports GHG emissions by transportation mode and province. For cars and passenger light trucks the two provinces together emit 39.0 Mt a year as inventoried — Ontario 24.0 Mt in 2022, Quebec 15.0 Mt in 2023. Heavy freight trucks add 18.2 Mt — Ontario 11.8, Quebec 6.4. Those are combustion figures; on the life-cycle boundary they become 63.6 and 22.9 Mt a year.

    Electrifying a car removes 76 per cent of its life-cycle emission on Ontario’s grid: 176 g per passenger-kilometre for an internal-combustion vehicle against 42 g for an electric one, the latter almost entirely battery manufacture rather than electricity. That figure is corroborated independently by TD Economics, which puts the Ontario saving at “around 80 per cent”. Electrifying a heavy truck removes 94 per cent — a battery-electric Class 8 at roughly 63 g per kilometre against diesel’s 1,134 g — because a 600 kWh battery is a far larger manufacturing debt than a car’s, but amortises over a 1.2 million kilometre working life.

    InputValueBasis
    Cars and light trucks, ON + QC39.0 Mt/yrNRCan Table 8, Ontario 2022 and Quebec 2023
    Heavy freight trucks, ON + QC18.2 Mt/yrNRCan Table 8
    Life-cycle multiplier, road passenger1.63Chester and Horvath (2009)
    Life-cycle multiplier, road freight1.26Chester and Horvath (2009)
    Emission removed, car to electric76 %176 → 42 g/pkm, IESO grid
    Emission removed, Class 8 to electric94 %1,134 → 63 g/km, 1.2M km life
    EV fleet share, cars, 2040 → 208015 % → 70 %post-repeal trajectory
    Electrification counterfactual2 % EV fleet, heldtoday’s fleet, frozen

    Table 3. Inputs to the electrification comparison. Road emissions from NRCan Table 8; life-cycle multipliers from Chester and Horvath (2009); grid intensity from the IESO 2025 Annual Planning Outlook. The fleet is held at today’s emission level across the period, on the assumption that growth in vehicle-kilometres and improvement in conventional efficiency broadly offset.

    ⚠ The trajectory used here is the one policy has already given up on

    The car trajectory is the post-repeal one. The federal Electric Vehicle Availability Standard, which required all new light-duty sales to be zero-emission by 2035, was paused in September 2025 and its repeal posted in the Canada Gazette in August 2026 with nothing in force to replace it. This note therefore models a slower fleet conversion than federal policy intended — which makes the electrification figures conservative, not generous.

    That gap is itself instructive. Restoring the mandate’s original trajectory would save a further 165 Mt over the same fifty years in these two provinces alone. One regulatory decision about car sales is worth roughly sixty-seven times ALTO’s entire fifty-year net carbon removal.

    What This Does and Does Not Show

    Four qualifications

    Four qualifications belong with the comparison, and the first is the one a reviewer will raise.

    These are not alternatives, and the figures do not compete

    Building a railway does not prevent electrifying a car fleet, and nothing here says the money should move from one to the other. The two savings add. The comparison establishes proportion, not a choice: it says what weight the carbon argument can bear in a case for ALTO, not whether ALTO should be built.

    The figures do not double-count

    ALTO’s credit is calculated on the electrification trajectory — that is precisely why it erodes over the period. The displaced car is getting cleaner whether or not the railway is built, and the railway’s credit shrinks accordingly.

    The electrification counterfactual is artificial

    Holding the fleet at a 2 per cent electric share for fifty years is not a forecast of anything; it is a device for measuring what conversion delivers. The realistic question is not whether electrification happens but how fast, which is why the car trajectory is taken from post-repeal policy rather than from ambition.

    The scope is deliberately narrow

    Ontario and Quebec road transport only, light-duty and heavy freight. It excludes medium trucks, marine, aviation and rail, and it excludes the rest of Canada. A wider scope would make ALTO’s share smaller, not larger.

    What remains after all four qualifications is a question of proportion that the project’s climate framing does not survive. A railway costing well over $100 billion on the Initiative’s own reference-class estimate, which does not repay its own construction carbon until 2083, removes in fifty years what the vehicle fleet beside it removes in about a month. If ALTO is to be justified, it will have to be justified on capacity, on journey time, or on regional development. It cannot be justified on carbon.

    Where things stand · November 2026

    Summary ledger

    Fifty years, 2040–2089, Ontario and Quebec, life-cycle comparison boundary throughout:

    1,097 Mt
    Car and light-truck electrification — on the post-repeal trajectory, against a frozen 2 per cent electric fleet. The largest single transport decarbonisation measure available in these provinces.
    154–668 Mt
    Heavy-truck electrification — range set by how fast long-haul freight converts. Trucks electrify better than cars per vehicle: 94 per cent of the life-cycle emission against 76.
    165 Mt
    The repealed EV mandate — what restoring the original federal trajectory would add, in these two provinces alone. Roughly sixty-seven times ALTO’s net removal.
    +22.6 Mt
    ALTO at upper ridership — 25.7 million passengers a year by 2080, above every independent forecast for the corridor, including those of McGill’s TRAM group, the Munk School, the C.D. Howe Institute and the federal government’s own 2021 business case.
    +2.5 Mt
    ALTO at central ridership — 12.5 million a year by 2080. Between 0.14 and 0.20 per cent of combined road electrification. Does not repay its construction carbon until 2083.
    −8.3 Mt
    ALTO at lower ridership — 6.1 million a year by 2080. Not a saving at all: the railway emits more over fifty years than it displaces, and never repays its construction debt.
    2110
    ALTO’s payback at the tailpipe boundary — the narrower accounting convention, which this note does not use. On the boundary favourable to the railway, payback is 2083.
    Download Full Note
    ALTO: A CO2 Rounding Error (PDF, 6 pages)
    Complete method, the fifty-year carbon account, annual and cumulative time series at both accounting boundaries, and full sources
    Download PDF
    The research behind the brief

    The brief above is a summary of a five-document research pack. Every figure it quotes is derived in one of these, and each is published in full so the arithmetic can be checked rather than taken on trust.

    Sources

    Primary documents and data

    1.
    Alto HSR Citizen Research Initiative, ALTO Lifecycle CO2 — Construction, Operational and Severance Input Notes, and the Fifty-Year Lifecycle CO2 Output Note, November 2026 update. citizenresearch.ca
    2.
    Alto HSR Citizen Research Initiative, Modal-Shift Note 3: Ridership Envelope and Phasing — the lower, central and upper trajectories used here. citizenresearch.ca
    3.
    Natural Resources Canada, Office of Energy Efficiency, Comprehensive Energy Use Database, Transportation Sector Table 8: GHG Emissions by Transportation Mode — Ontario (2022) and Quebec (2023). oee.nrcan.gc.ca
    4.
    M. Chester and A. Horvath, “Environmental assessment of passenger transportation should include infrastructure and supply chains,” Environmental Research Letters 4 (2009) — the life-cycle multipliers over tailpipe-only accounting. transportationlca.org
    5.
    TD Economics, Lifecycle Emissions: Electric vs Gasoline Vehicles in Canada — Ontario life-cycle saving of “around 80 per cent”; 15,000 km a year over an 18-year vehicle life. economics.td.com
    6.
    Pembina Institute, Zero by 2040: Canada’s Pathway to Net-Zero for Medium- and Heavy-Duty Trucks and Buses — the truck conversion trajectories; long-haul Class 8 identified as the laggard segment. pembina.org
    7.
    Independent Electricity System Operator, Annual Planning Outlook 2025 — Ontario grid emissions trajectory to 2050. ieso.ca
    8.
    Environment and Climate Change Canada, Electric Vehicle Availability Standard — paused September 2025; repeal posted in the Canada Gazette, August 2026. canada.ca