Tag: Oakervee Review

  • Close to carbon neutral

    “Close to Carbon Neutral”

    How the UK government added up the carbon cost of HS2 — and what that means for the climate claims made for ALTO.

    ⚠ Why this matters for ALTO

    High-speed rail is often described as a climate solution. Britain’s HS2 is the closest recent example of a large new high-speed line, and the UK government published its carbon sums in detail. Those sums never showed a clear climate benefit within the standard 60-year period. A review commissioned by the government called the project “close to carbon neutral” — meaning it was not clear whether HS2 would cut emissions or add to them. Oakervee Review

    ALTO would be about four and a half times the length of the section of HS2 now being built. ALTO has not yet published the figures needed to check its own carbon case.

    The Short Version

    Building a high-speed railway releases a large amount of carbon up front. Concrete, steel, tunnels and earthworks all have a carbon cost, and nearly all of it is paid before the first train runs.

    The carbon savings come later, slowly, over decades. They depend on how many people stop flying or driving and take the train instead.

    For HS2, the up-front cost and the 60-year savings came out at roughly the same size. Whether the final answer was a small saving or a small increase depended on the assumptions used. When each section of HS2 was assessed on its own, every section showed a net increase in emissions. Most of the savings depended on people giving up domestic flights — mainly flights to Scotland served by the northern parts of HS2 that have since been cut back or cancelled.

    The lesson for ALTO: a carbon claim is only as good as the numbers behind it. Those numbers — construction carbon, tunnel length, and where the passengers would come from — have not yet been published for ALTO.

    Download
    “Close to Carbon Neutral” — Full Comparative Brief (PDF)
    Four official UK carbon assessments of HS2, 2013–2022, with full figures, tables and references
    Download PDF
    The Numbers

    Three figures that tell the story

    Carbon is measured here in million tonnes of carbon dioxide equivalent (written “Mt”). “Equivalent” means other greenhouse gases are converted into the amount of carbon dioxide that would have the same warming effect. These are the figures HS2’s builder, HS2 Ltd, gave the government’s review of the project in 2019–20, for the full network as it was then planned.

    8–14 Mt
    carbon released by building the full HS2 network
    HS2 Ltd, via Oakervee Review
    11–12 Mt
    carbon saved over the first 60 years of running trains
    HS2 Ltd, via Oakervee Review
    −4 to +3 Mt
    overall result: anywhere from a small saving to a small increase
    Oakervee Review, para. 5.37

    Put simply: the carbon spent building HS2 and the carbon saved by running it over 60 years are about the same size. If construction comes in at the low end, HS2 saves a little. If it comes in at the high end, HS2 adds a little. That is why the review described the result as close to zero rather than as a clear climate gain.

    These figures were also calculated for a bigger network than will now be built. The eastern branch to Leeds was dropped in 2021, and the Birmingham–Manchester branch was cancelled in 2023. The Initiative has not found a published carbon reassessment for the smaller scheme.

    How the Sum Works

    What goes on each side of the carbon ledger

    Every official HS2 carbon assessment builds its answer from the same basic pieces. Some pieces add carbon. Others are counted as savings.

    Adds carbon: building the railway

    Tunnels, cuttings, embankments, viaducts and bridges, and the concrete and steel they need. This is the biggest single item, and it is paid up front. The government’s review pointed out that high-speed lines need very straight routes and gentle slopes, which means more digging, more tunnelling and more concrete.

    Adds carbon: running the trains

    The electricity the trains use, plus extra car trips to and from the new stations. How much carbon this adds depends on how clean the electricity grid is.

    Saves carbon: people switching from planes

    Travellers who would otherwise have taken a domestic flight. For the full HS2 network, this was by far the largest saving — about three-quarters of all the savings from people changing how they travel (Initiative calculation from the 2013 assessment).

    Saves carbon: people switching from cars and older trains

    Travellers who would otherwise have driven or taken a slower existing train. This saving gets smaller as cars become electric, because the cars being replaced are themselves cleaner.

    Saves carbon: freight and trees

    Moving passenger trains onto HS2 frees up space on older lines. The assessments assumed that space would be filled by freight trains taking lorries off the road. They also counted carbon absorbed by about four million newly planted trees.

    The Official Record · 2013–2022

    Four assessments, one consistent pattern

    Between 2013 and 2022 the UK government published several carbon assessments for HS2, prepared by or for HS2 Ltd. They cover different sections and different time spans, so their totals cannot simply be added together. But they tell the same story: no assessment showed a clear net saving over construction plus 60 years, and every section assessed on its own showed an increase.

    Could go either way
    Full network, 2013 (the original London–Birmingham–Manchester–Leeds plan). Overall result ranged from a saving of about 2.5 Mt to an increase of about 3.8 Mt, depending on design and assumptions. The assessment said that over construction and the first 60 years, savings would be less than emissions, largely because of construction.
    Net increase
    Phase One, London to the West Midlands, 2013. The only section now being built. Construction: 5.3–6.5 Mt. Running savings over 60 years: about 3 Mt. Overall: an increase of about 2.1–2.6 Mt (Initiative calculation from the published figures).
    Could go either way
    Oakervee Review, 2020 (government-commissioned review, using HS2 Ltd’s updated full-network figures). From a saving of 3–4 Mt to an increase of 1–3 Mt. Conclusion: “close to carbon neutral.”
    Net increase
    Phase 2a, West Midlands to Crewe, 2021. An increase of 1.43 Mt after 60 years and 1.46 Mt after 120 years, as stated in the assessment itself. Doubling the time span barely changed the answer.
    Net increase
    Crewe to Manchester, 2022 (since cancelled). An increase of about 6.9 Mt over 120 years (Initiative calculation from the published figures).

    The pattern matters. The claimed savings only appeared when the whole network was added up — and a large part of those whole-network savings came from the northern sections that have since been cut.

    The Assumptions

    Four choices that decide the answer

    Because the carbon cost and the carbon savings are so close in size, small changes in a few assumptions decide whether the result is a saving or an increase.

    1. How many people give up flying

    Domestic flights were the largest single saving in the full-network figures. The government’s review expected domestic flights to fall by about 11% after HS2, with half of that on London–Scotland routes. Those routes depended on the northern sections of HS2 — the sections that were later dropped or cancelled.

    2. How fast cars become electric

    The 2013 assessment ran two scenarios. In the one that assumed cleaner cars sooner, the carbon saved by taking people out of cars fell by 86% (Initiative calculation). The cleaner cars become, the smaller the advantage of the train over driving.

    3. Whether freed-up track is used for freight

    The assessments counted a sizeable saving from freight trains using space freed on older lines. That depends on decisions about how the track is used — decisions that HS2 Ltd does not control.

    4. How much carbon construction really releases

    HS2 Ltd set a target to cut construction carbon in half compared with its own earlier forecast. Its latest progress report records a 35% reduction against that baseline. These are figures HS2 Ltd reports about itself.

    How It Was Presented

    Accurate figures that leave out the bottom line

    In the documents used to make decisions, HS2’s carbon was usually described in two ways:

    “Per passenger, per kilometre”

    The Phase One business case said HS2 would produce about 8 grams of carbon per passenger per kilometre by 2030, compared with 22 grams for existing intercity trains, 67 for cars and 170 for domestic flights. These numbers describe a train in operation. They do not include the carbon released in building the line.

    “A small share of the national total”

    Environmental statements described HS2’s construction carbon as a small percentage of Britain’s national carbon budgets. That compares one project with the whole economy.

    Both ways of describing the figures are accurate as far as they go. But neither one tells you the net result — carbon spent against carbon saved over the life of the project. That is the number the government’s own review described as close to zero.

    Comparison · HS2 and ALTO

    What we can and cannot compare

    Most of the engineering details that drove HS2’s construction carbon — how much of the route is in tunnel, in deep cuttings or on viaducts — have not been published for ALTO’s corridor.

    HS2 Phase One (London–West Midlands)ALTO (Toronto–Québec City)
    Route length
    225 kmAbout 1,000 km — roughly four and a half times longer
    Stations
    4 new stations7: Toronto, Peterborough, Ottawa, Montréal, Laval, Trois-Rivières, Québec City
    Tunnels
    52 km of twin tunnels — about 23% of the route. Tunnels and cuttings together: about 55%Not published
    Viaducts and bridges
    52 viaducts, 175 bridgesNot published
    Cost
    £87.7–102.7 billion (2025 prices, whole remaining programme)C$60–90 billion (ALTO); C$75–113 billion (Parliamentary Budget Officer)
    Carbon from construction
    5.3–6.5 Mt — about 24–29 thousand tonnes per kilometre (Initiative calculation)Not published
    First trains
    Between 2036 and 2039Construction from 2029; Ottawa–Montréal first
    An illustration, not an estimate

    If a 1,000 km line were built with the same construction carbon per kilometre as HS2 Phase One, building it would release about 24–29 Mt of carbon. ALTO’s real figure could be higher or lower. It would depend on how much tunnelling, rock cutting and bridging the route needs — none of which has been published. This simple sum shows why those engineering details matter so much to the carbon question.

    Implications for ALTO

    Six questions to ask of any ALTO carbon claim

    HS2 shows that a high-speed railway’s carbon case depends on construction carbon, the time span chosen, and where the passengers come from — much more than on how clean the trains are in service. These questions follow.

    About the sums

    Is construction carbon included? HS2’s “per passenger” figures left it out. A fair comparison shows building and running together, over 60 and 120 years.
    Where do the passengers come from? HS2’s savings rested mainly on people giving up flights. For ALTO, how many riders would come from planes, cars and existing VIA Rail trains? Without that split, the carbon claim cannot be checked against the ridership forecast.
    Is each section assessed on its own? The federal government has said each ALTO section will have its own impact assessment. On HS2, every section on its own showed an increase, even when the full network was said to save carbon.

    About Canada’s conditions

    What car fleet is assumed? On HS2, assuming electric cars sooner cut the road saving by 86%. Trains running in Ontario and Québec from the 2030s to the 2090s face the same question.
    What does a clean grid change? Ontario and Québec electricity is already largely low-carbon. That keeps the trains’ running emissions low — but it also narrows the gap between a train and an electric car, and leaves little room for the future grid improvements HS2’s long-term figures relied on.
    How much tunnelling, rock cutting and bridging? On HS2, these drove construction carbon. For ALTO, the equivalent questions are the route across the Canadian Shield, the Rideau system and the river crossings.

    Federal impact assessments include a climate review — the Strategic Assessment of Climate Change — which asks project builders to estimate their greenhouse-gas emissions and explain how the project fits Canada’s 2050 net-zero commitment. That is where these questions can be put on the public record.

    Where Things Stand · November 2026

    Summary

    HS2 record
    No official assessment found a clear net carbon saving over construction plus 60 years. The government’s review called it “close to carbon neutral.”
    HS2 record
    Every section assessed on its own — Phase One, Phase 2a, Crewe–Manchester — showed a net increase.
    HS2 record
    The full-network savings rested mainly on people giving up domestic flights, largely on routes served by northern sections that have since been dropped or cancelled.
    HS2 record
    No published carbon reassessment has been found for the smaller HS2 now being built.
    ALTO
    Construction carbon, tunnel share, cuttings and viaducts: not published.
    ALTO
    Where riders would come from (planes, cars, existing trains): not published as a breakdown that can be checked against the carbon case.
    ALTO
    A federal climate review is part of the impact assessment process — the place these figures can be required and examined.

    HS2 is not ALTO. The routes, the landscape, the electricity grid and the travel market are all different. But HS2’s published record shows that a high-speed railway’s climate benefit cannot be assumed; it has to be shown, with construction carbon and passenger sources set out in full. For ALTO, those figures are still to come.

    Download Full Brief
    “Close to Carbon Neutral”: How the UK Government Modelled the Carbon of HS2 (PDF, 7 pages)
    Full assessment-by-assessment figures, model components, scenario tables, HS2–ALTO comparison and 19 references
    Download PDF
    Sources

    Primary documents

    1.
    Temple-ERM for HS2 Ltd, HS2 and Carbon: Assessment of carbon emissions for Phase One and Two, Sustainability Statement, Appendix F, October 2013. gov.uk
    2.
    HS2 Ltd, London–West Midlands Environmental Statement, Volume 3: Route-wide effects, November 2013. gov.uk
    3.
    HS2 Ltd, Phase 2a Information Paper E27: Carbon, version 1.3, 11 February 2021. gov.uk
    4.
    Department for Transport, Oakervee Review of HS2, February 2020. gov.uk
    5.
    Department for Transport, Full Business Case: High Speed 2 Phase One, April 2020. gov.uk
    6.
    HS2 Ltd, High Speed Rail (Crewe–Manchester) Environmental Statement, Volume 3: Route-wide effects (M32), January 2022. gov.uk
    7.
    HS2 Ltd, Environmental Sustainability Progress Report 2025–2026. gov.uk
    8.
    Alto, Frequently Asked Questions (route length, stations, speed, ridership). altotrain.ca
    9.
    Government of Canada, Major Projects Office, Alto High-Speed Rail. canada.ca
    10.
    Environment and Climate Change Canada, Strategic Assessment of Climate Change, 2020.
    11.
    The full brief lists all 19 references, including sources for HS2’s tunnel share, cost, cancelled sections and the Parliamentary Budget Officer’s ALTO cost range. Full brief (PDF)

    Figures marked “Initiative calculation” are sums or percentages of figures published in the documents above; they are reconstructions, not independent measurements. HS2 Ltd’s construction-carbon progress figures are self-reported. This brief makes no statement about the motives or conduct of any person or organisation.