Why is Alto so hard to sell

Opinion

Why Is It So Hard to Sell ALTO?

Canadians like the idea of fast trains. The project is a harder sell, because hard questions are being answered with marketing instead of numbers.

On November 12, Quebec’s farmers’ union, the UPA, released a study showing the existing rail corridor between Quebec City and Toronto could be modernised for about $11 billion. Within hours, ALTO, the Crown corporation behind the $60- to $90-billion high-speed rail project, issued a rebuttal, and its chief executive was on the radio. That speed tells us something. Canadians like the idea of fast trains. ALTO is struggling to sell this one because it keeps answering hard questions with marketing instead of numbers.

86%
supported high-speed trains in Canada, as an idea
EKOS, 2009
25%
strongly support ALTO itself
Abacus Data, March 2026
Split
on whether ALTO should be a government priority
Nanos, summer 2026

Start with the idea. In 2009, an EKOS survey found 86 per cent of Canadians supported high-speed trains. Last year, the federal government’s own internal polling found 65 per cent support for a Toronto–Quebec City line. As a concept, it barely needs a pitch.

Now ask about ALTO itself, with a cost, a route and a priority attached. This spring, Probe Research found it was both the most-supported and the most-opposed of Ottawa’s major projects. Abacus Data found only 25 per cent strongly support it. By summer, Nanos found Canadians evenly split on whether it should be a government priority. The polls ask different questions, but the pattern is clear. The closer the question gets to the real project, the softer the support.

The real project has become hard to ignore. A 300 km/h line must be fenced, with every road and farm lane bridged or closed. It will cut through farms, wildlife corridors and towns that will get no station. Farm groups in Ontario and Quebec have refused ALTO’s collaboration agreement and asked for an independent review. Municipalities have been asked to sign non-disclosure agreements before being briefed. The Parliamentary Budget Officer puts construction at $75 to $113 billion, and that assumes European costs. On British or American experience, it would be higher.

How does ALTO respond? With promotion. Its television ads show sleek trains and none of the fencing. Asked on Quebec radio why ALTO advertises so heavily, its chief executive said the goal is to reach “not just people’s heads, but sometimes their hearts.”

When the questions get specific, the answers stop. A 2024 business case shown to deputy ministers was released under Access to Information with most pages withheld. ALTO says it will not publish a benefit-cost ratio yet. Asked how it analysed what thousands of people told its consultation, ALTO withheld its method. Transport Canada released its full method for a similar consultation on the Billy Bishop airport.

The November 12 reply followed the same pattern. ALTO said high-speed rail would deliver five times the economic benefit of the farmers’ option. But the comparison was against a $45- to $75-billion new railway nobody has proposed, not the $11-billion upgrade on the table. For a comparison of the actual options, ALTO’s release offered an email address. Our brief The Option Nobody Priced sets that reply out claim by claim.

This explains the polls. An idea only needs to be appealing. A project that could cost more than $100 billion needs its numbers shown: what it costs, what it returns, what it takes from the communities it crosses, and how it compares with cheaper ways to get better trains.

Canadians are not against fast trains. They are being asked to back one train, on one route, at one price, without the facts to judge it. Advertising can make people like an idea. It cannot tell a farmer where the fence will go, or tell a taxpayer what $90 billion buys.

What Ottawa should require

Before another dollar goes to advertising, Ottawa should require ALTO to publish three things: the business case, the full cost estimate, and an independent comparison with upgrading the existing line. If the project is as good as its backers say, the numbers will sell it. If they won’t, Canadians deserve to know that now, before the land is taken.

Status of the figures

Published figures on this page are quoted from the named sources and can be checked there. Poll results come from surveys that asked different questions and are not combined into a trend. The chief executive’s radio remark is an English translation of a French-language interview. Where ALTO has not published something, we say so rather than infer its contents, and we make no claim about why any figure was or was not published.

Sources

Polls, documents and statements

1.EKOS Research for the Railway Association of Canada, November 2009, as reported by Railway Age. railwayage.com
2.Internal PCO/PMO polling, May 2025, as reported by Global News. globalnews.ca
3.Probe Research, April 2026, as reported by The Canadian Press. ctvnews.ca
4.Abacus Data, March 19–24, 2026, as reported in ALTNO’s release of March 31, 2026. newswire.ca
5.Nanos Research for CTV News, 2026. ctvnews.ca
6.Office of the Parliamentary Budget Officer, Canada’s Eastern Corridor High-Speed Rail: A Cost Analysis using Global Data, RP-2627-009-C, October 1, 2026.
7.ALTO, news release, Canada Newswire, November 12, 2026. newswire.ca
8.Martin Imbleau interview on La commission, November 12, 2026, from an English translation posted by Stone Mills Against Alto.
9.Vision Transport, Corridor Québec-Toronto : ce que la voie existante permet, November 2026. tgf.corda.consulting
10.The Alto Files, “Five Times What?,” November 12, 2026, on ATI release A-2026-00195. thealtofiles.substack.com
11.Initiative briefs: The Option Nobody Priced (November 2026); One Shows Its Work. One Doesn’t. (October 2026); City of Kingston: Bound Before Briefed (July 2026).